Talk:Domine, quis habitabit (Thomas Tallis)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

CPDL #30328

Comments by Mick Swithinbank:

  • Possible error in bars 191-2, Discantus's tied note: could be C rather than D.
  • Bars 13 & 184: Bass's Es should probably be editorially flattened.
  • Bar 126: the discrepancy in duration of the Gs sung by Superius and Contratenor will sound untidy, and there is no obvious justification for it.
  • Bar 130: unless Discantus's F sharp is reduced to a minim, the false relation will be an exceptionally startling one.
  • Bars 156 & 175: there is a curious hiatus, with none of the voices moving; this may work better in performance if the non-event is reduced by a semibreve.