Talk:Ego flos campi a 7 (Jacobus Clemens non Papa)

From ChoralWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Errors in CPDL #98

m.5, Sop II, read c for d
m.8, Sop II, underlay needs "-li-" on E
mm.11-12, Ten II, tie missing
mm.22-23, Alto, tie missing
m. 74, Alto, read c for g

Courtesy of Saint Louis Chamber Chorus. --Bobnotts talk 11:11, 27 March 2008 (PDT)

A further error can be found in bars 43-44, where the alto and first bass appear to sing in parallel octaves, only with different words. Andrew Maruzzella's edition shows the solution to be as follows: the last note in bar 43 should be F in the alto, D in the first bass. The same source confirms the suspicion that second bass's note in bar 41 should be a minim, undotted. - Mick Swithinbank 17:54, 29 October 2010 (UTC)