Category talk:Hymn meters

Consulting the metrical indices for hymn tunes in sundry hymnals, there seem to be two major systems of organization. However, finding 88.88 in a hymntune index is rare; this meter is almost always categorized as "LM", and the listings for the three customary abbreviations (SM, CM, LM) and their derivatives, "with refrain", and the abbreviations for the doubled forms- SMD, CMD, LMD, all precede the numerically designated categories.

This organizations system may be worth consideration.

ns 2006 April 11 1708 CDT

There probably eventually needs to be a "search tips" section, to warn users of certain metrical pitfalls, e.g., that an 87.87.87.87 tune may fit iambic but not trochaic texts, or vice versa, or that a text with a meter 87.87.337 may have been fitted to a tune with a meter of 87.87.67. Also, capitalization matters, at least for the first character.

ns 2006 April 11 1713 CDT.

The hymn tune categories with more than nine syllables in the first line, should not be listed under "1". I know this is possible, and will work it out at some point in the near future; if someone else does it before I get to it, a brief description about how it is accomplished would be valuable.

ns 2006 April 11 1732 CDT

On the category page of each hymn metre with 10 or more syllables in the first line, say for example the category [[Category:10.10.10]], assign the category like this:

[[Category:Hymn meters|~10.10.10]]

The metre will then be grouped along with the ~ character, which sorts after 9, and is at least a slight improvement on having these metres sort under the heading of 1.

--Pml 01:03:24, 2006-04-12 (PDT)

Hmmm. Number of syllables are going to be a problem with any case where one or more lines has more than nine syllables, but a review of meters in several hymns reveals that none contains hymns with more than 15 syllables in a line. This suggests to me that the most expedient means of organizing the meters category is to use hexadecimal numbering, so that 10 is listed as a, 11 as b, 12 as c, 13 as d, 14 as e, and 15 as f. An explanatory note to the effect will be needed in the page for those who are not familiar with hexadecimal numbering, but at least there is no hexadecimal mathematic required. This will allow lines to sort properly, preclude the need to come up with five other characters besides, and have the number of syllable sort correctly.

ns 2006 April 12 1517 CDT