Talk:Ave Maria a 4 (Jacob Handl): Difference between revisions
m (moved Victoria Ave Maria a 4 to live at Handl Ave Maria a 4 instead) |
m (template) |
||
(3 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Attribution == | |||
This work should be attributed to [[Jacobus Gallus]], a contemporary of Victoria. | This work should be attributed to [[Jacobus Gallus]], a contemporary of Victoria. | ||
There is a manuscript of this work available. | There is a manuscript of this work available. | ||
For the 2003 article that attributes this work to Gallus: see this link: [http://www.thezaurus.com/?/webzine/gallus_and_the_mystery_of_authorship/ Gallus and the mystery of authorship] | For the 2003 article that attributes this work to Gallus: see this link: [http://www.thezaurus.com/indexcc3c.html?/webzine/gallus_and_the_mystery_of_authorship/ Gallus and the mystery of authorship] | ||
[[User:Avemariasongs|Avemariasongs]] 12:01, 30 March 2011 (CDT) | [[User:Avemariasongs|Avemariasongs]] 12:01, 30 March 2011 (CDT) | ||
Line 16: | Line 17: | ||
Per further discussion, I've moved the page for the Ave Maria a 4 to live under Jacob Handl's name, with the Victoria Ave Maria a 4 simply serving as a redirect for it. | Per further discussion, I've moved the page for the Ave Maria a 4 to live under Jacob Handl's name, with the Victoria Ave Maria a 4 simply serving as a redirect for it. | ||
}} | }} | ||
== Errors in all uploaded versions == | |||
All versions, which have been uploaded as yet, are faulty. | |||
Here a summary list of mistakes: | |||
* sometimes no leading note | |||
* ending must be on a major chord after cadence/clausula, not minor (minor endings are untypical for the 16th century (Renaissance). First in Baroque, e. g. at J. S. Bach, can be the last chord in minor). | |||
* some wrong Tenor clausulae sfuggitae instead of Tenor clausula formalis/regularis (go to the third; conventional Tenor clausulae lead to the fundamental tone (root)) | |||
I will revise this sheet and upload a correct version. {{Unsigned|Ascomu|08:26, 11 June 2011 }} |
Latest revision as of 00:13, 13 May 2020
Attribution
This work should be attributed to Jacobus Gallus, a contemporary of Victoria.
There is a manuscript of this work available.
For the 2003 article that attributes this work to Gallus: see this link: Gallus and the mystery of authorship
Avemariasongs 12:01, 30 March 2011 (CDT)
|
|
Errors in all uploaded versions
All versions, which have been uploaded as yet, are faulty. Here a summary list of mistakes:
- sometimes no leading note
- ending must be on a major chord after cadence/clausula, not minor (minor endings are untypical for the 16th century (Renaissance). First in Baroque, e. g. at J. S. Bach, can be the last chord in minor).
- some wrong Tenor clausulae sfuggitae instead of Tenor clausula formalis/regularis (go to the third; conventional Tenor clausulae lead to the fundamental tone (root))
I will revise this sheet and upload a correct version. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by Ascomu (talk • contribs) on 08:26, 11 June 2011 .