ChoralWiki:Pages awaiting cleanup
(Redirected from Category:Pages awaiting cleanup)
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
The pages listed here have been categorised as requiring cleanup by someone using template Cleanup. These pages contain errors which need fixing: invalid characters, faulty code, or whatever. They are ordered by the date they were last changed (most recent first), which is not necessarily the same date they were included in this list.
Pages with broken links, pages awaiting deletion, pages which have been recommended for merger and recommended for splitting are listed in separate categories.
| Page title | Description of cleanup required |
|---|---|
| Ave Regina coelorum (Felice Anerio) | CPDL #27890 here seems to be the same work as CPDL #27898: Ave Regina coelorum II (Gregor Aichinger). The Ave Regina coelorum in Musica Divina Vol. III (Carl Proske) is |
| Decantabat populus | Though "variant" is used in its correct sense (rather than as something added), it's not easily possible to figure out what the actual text of any work is: Tolius' minor variants aren't given on work page |
| Deutsche Messe, D872 (Franz Schubert) | There's no mention of transpositions in any edition notes; even SATB versions are often lowered to a congregational singing key… |
| Jubilate Deo (Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart) | Needs Köchel number: is this spurious, an arrangement, or…? |
| Gaude Maria Virgo | comparisons to given text still needed in most cases |
| Be Thou my vision (Traditional) | These 'alt.' versions agree neither with the 1912 publication nor with the CPDL editions; please ID sources! |
| Funeral sentences from the BCP | No link to BCP; unclear how many 'Dirge anthems' there are in total or what order they go |
| Chorale prelude, By your kingly power (Richard Perrignon) | This is indeed different to Chorale prelude, 'By your Priestly Power' (Richard Perrignon) but seems based on the same tune. Instrumental voluntaries seem not to have been foreseen for CPDL, though they certainly have a place in the choir. |
| Michael Praetorius | Some works labeled "prima pars" have been merged, some have links to second half, but some do not. See discussion at Talk:Hor che'l ciel e la terra (Claudio Monteverdi)Richard Mix (talk) 07:01, 25 June 2014 (UTC) |
| Tirsi morir volea (D'Incerto) | This seems to duplicate Tirsi morir volea (Anonymous) though I haven't made a detailed comparison to CPDL #35582 yet |
| Carols for Choirs 1 | Existing editions should be searched & linked. Richard Mix 02:42, 1 September 2011 (CDT) sortable table makes a merge with Carols for Choirs 3, Carols for Choirs 2, and the currently in-print reissue 100 Carols For Choirs seem more useful than 4 separate pages. Richard Mix 02:42, 1 September 2011 (CDT) |
| Copyright Issues FAQ | No pages link here. |
| Verbum caro factum est | some works listed are for a different (communion) text: "Verbum caro panem verum" |
| Scio enim quod Redemptor (Orlando di Lasso) | Publication history may need straightening |
| Sharon Rutherford | Score pages need to be created for entries below |
| Laurentius Schlemmer | addwork form was not submitted, leaving note on user's Talk page 2011-05-02 |
| Gerry Kapoh | Works pages need to be created |
| André Ribeiro | work page has to be created yet |
| Otto Olsson | Is there a copyright issue, regarding composer date of death? |
| José Ángel Lamas | needs to have score for Popule meus listed properly |
| Jeremiah Clarke | Easily confused with Clarke [Clark], Jeremiah (ii)
(b Worcester, c1743; d Bromsgrove, 11 May 1809) and even with John Clark |
| Harry Fragson | Work's page neeeds to be created |
| Giovanni Paolo Cima | As amusing as the idea of brothers distinguishable only by their middle names is, the dates and information here are inconsistent with New Grove |
| Gerhard Hafner | There is a redlink to a nonexistent work page for Ja - Meine Hoffnung which needs to be created. -- Chucktalk Giffen♫ 13:57, 25 June 2009 (UTC) |
| Claudio Casciolini | Veni Creator Spiritus, Sacris solemniis, and Panis angelicus a 4 all appear to be the same music |
| Benjamin Ipavec | Score page needs to be created for "Ciganka Marija" |
| Maksim Sozontovich Berezovsky | Above link needs to be submitted correctly |
| Miller | Rather sparse! Do we even know that Miller is a composer instead of a tune name? See these leads. Richard Mix 18:19, 18 June 2011 (CDT) |
| Lyle K. Neff | a works page needs to be created for Russian Prayer |
| Groh | apparently neither Johann Groh (1575-1627, see IMSLP) nor Heinrich Groh but a romantic; could he be Otto Emmerich? UE has a page with blank biography… |
| Giovanni Andrea Cima | As amusing as the idea of brothers distinguishable only by their middle names is, New Grove and German WP give only "Andrea Cima" |
| David Evan Thomas | work needs to be submitted to obtain a CPDL number, and workspage needs to be created |
| Ecce advenit (Heinrich Isaac) | Alleluia vidimus stellam (Heinrich Isaac) & Vidimus stellam (Heinrich Isaac) are red links on publ. page; Festa Christi (Heinrich Isaac) unedited. Would a split of CPDL 35844 be desirable, or separate pages for Introit & Officium in Epiphaniae Dom.? |
| Veni Creator Spiritus (Polyphonic form) | No addscore submission received, no catalog # assigned. How to handle small facsimiles of hand-written score? |
| The Great Flood (1967) (Caroline S. Arnold) | Item requires 4 separate files due to 10 meg limit. I finagled something that might work. Also correct Voicing? rademattia |
| O voso galo, comadre (Traditional) | Possible copyright infringement |
| O Salutaris (Edward Elgar) | disambiguation or at least a source highly desirable! |
| Martin Zalba | The above linked scores need to be indexed properly. Bobnotts 14:08, 8 February 2007 (PST) |
| In dulci jubilo (Johann Sebastian Bach) | CPDLno 1970 is a different harmonization, not included in Richter's 389 |
| Send out Thy light (Charles Gounod) | much abridged text |
| Peccantem me quotidie | Unclear what the exact text is for different pieces: Byrd, Gesualdo, Lasso, Mouton & Palestrina for example only go thru line 5. |
| Kheruvimskaya pyesn no. 1 (Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky) | Several district settings have been merged to this page. 2 editions are now split of to Kheruvimskaya pyesn, Op. 41 No. 6 (Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky). There is a start at disambiguation at Heruvimskaya Pesn' |
| Tota pulchra es Maria | There is now a disambiguation page Tota pulchra es and a Tota pulchra es, amica mea page. Of the works below only Kempter and the Lasso duet have not been checked. Richard Mix (talk) 02:32, 7 March 2017 (UTC) |
| Ode on the Dissolution of Time (M. Belknap) | It would be highly desirable to identify the composer's first name. |
| Salve Regina (Gioachino Rossini) | What is the actual title? "Motetto" (Carus Verlag), motet op.140 n°2 (fr:wp), "Salve O Vergine Maria" (incipit, not a 'variant text' but an Italian paraphrase)? The closest match I can find in NG is "Salve amabilis Maria (‘Hymne à la musique’)" (Péchés XI; Rossini Gesellschaft calls this "Mottetto dedicato a Maria Santissima Annunziata") Richard Mix (talk) 23:42, 15 February 2015 (UTC) |
| Passio secundum Mathaeum (Tomás Luis de Victoria) | The beginning at Matt. 26:14 (instead of the beginning of the chapter, as in LU) corresponds to the Revised Common Lectionary. The rest of the English [text] is however incomplete from here the end! |
| Benedictus (Orlando di Lasso) | Larger work unidentified |
| In notte placida (François Couperin) | surely an arrangement? |
| 21 hymn tunes (Caradog Roberts) | A list of tunes & meters would be useful |
| Quem vidistis | Explanation of bracketed text and which pieces they apply to is missing |
| About Copyright | Reviewing as part of Copyright info consolidation project -- Vaarky 07:18, 16 September 2009 (UTC) |
| Peter Gerloff | corresponding Score description pages on CPDL need to be created -- Vaarky 06:35, 18 May 2010 (UTC) |
| Jesu dulcis memoria | It's not yet clear how much of the text is included in most of these settings |
| Dum complerentur | It's really far too messy at present to figure out which piece has which text |
| In monte Oliveti | can't tell which version of text is used in M. Haydn setting; can't find "C) Verumtamen non sicut ego volo, sed sicut tu vis" anywhere… |
| Viri Galilaei | There are at least three texts with this incipit to sort out |
| How can I update my previously uploaded edition? | this page need to be updated |
| Printing-Viewing FAQ | No pages link here. Is this advice appropriate any more? |
| Tea-kettos.MUS | Composer Franz Lehár died in 1948, but this piece belongs to operetta Das Land des Lächelns which was first performed in 1929. I'm not sure about the copyright status. |
